ARC Review: A Murder Most Fowl by Carmela Dutra

Read time: 2 minutes

Book blurb:

Beth and her twin sister never expected their small-town life would suddenly take a turn for the sinister. When a murder shocks the community, Beth finds herself navigating secrets, lies, and unusual suspects—all while balancing complicated family ties and newfound friendships. With the help of her witty twin (whether she wants it or not) and loyal companion Rylie, Beth digs deeper than anyone else dares. The closer she gets to the truth, the more danger she faces, making it clear: this cozy little town isn’t as harmless as it seems.

Let’s talk about the book:

One of the most comforting and amazing cozy mysteries I’ve read this year, Murder Most Fowl by Carmela Dutra goes straight onto my favorites shelf, right up there with Vicki Delaney and Carol J. Perry. This book reminded me why I adore cozy mysteries.  Murder Most Fowl has everything I crave: the charm of small-town life, a cast of colorful characters, and an intriguing whodunit that managed to keep me guessing until the end.

What stood out most, though, was the heart in these pages. The portrayal of sibling love between the twins felt so authentic. It’s that perfect push-and-pull dynamic of love and exasperation that only a sibling relationship brings. Add in Beth’s effortless and genuine friendship with Rylie, and suddenly this wasn’t just a cozy mystery, it was a warm slice of life with people I didn’t want to leave behind.

It was with a heavy heart that I finished reading the book. I didn’t want to exit the world of Seth, Beth, and Rylie. And oh my goodness, Tina Wolstencroft’s narration is incredible. She gives Beth her own personality with such precision and charm, it feels like she stepped right out of Carmela’s imagination.

I can’t wait for the next book in what I hope will be a long, long, looooong series. Carmela Dutra has just earned a permanent place on my cozy mystery reading list.

Would I recommend it?

Heck yes! A Murder Most Fowl is a total delight! It’s got that warm, twisty vibe I crave, with a mystery that keeps you hooked and characters you’ll want to hang with. Tina Wolstencroft’s narration is next-level, making every moment pop. If you’re into sibling shenanigans, food truck fun, and a killer you won’t see coming, add this to your TBR pronto. I’m already dying for the next in this epic series.

What about you?

Who’s grabbing A Murder Most Fowl when it drops? Got a favorite cozy mystery duo that rivals Beth and Seth? Spill the tea in the comments. I’m ready to geek out over your cozy faves!

Pre-book your copy today:

Amazon CA
Goodreads
Visit Carmela Dutra on her author webpage

Thank you NetGalley for the advance copy!